Such matters are normally brought before the court by means of a written application instituting proceedings3. The law as applicable is summarized in article 38 of the icj statute and it is based on international conventions, international custom, and the general principles of law recognized by civilized nations. Full text available on the oxford journals site in pdf format. History of article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice introduction this contribution to the handbook presents and analyses history of article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice the icj or the court. The international court of justice article 92the international court of justice shall be the principal judicial organ of the united nations. Article 17 consent to be bound by part of a treaty and choice of differing provisions. Sources of international law article 38, icj statute international conventions, general principles, customary international law, judicial decisions, teachings of scholars. Treatment in hungary of aircraft and crew of the united states of america united states of america v. Nothing in the present charter shall impair the inherent right of. International law discussion questions gleider hernandez, international law oxford university press, 2019 chapter 2, the sources of international law question 1.
Sources of international law in the light of the article 38 of the international court of justice by shagufta. Article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice icj statute was not introduced. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. Article 38 1 of the statute of the international court of justice is generally recognized as a definitive statement of the sources of international law. The statute of tjhe international colurt of justice. The international court of justice and the judicial. States parties having accepted the jurisdiction of the court. Article 77 applicable penalties 38 article 78 determination of the sentence 38 article 79 trust fund 38 article 80 nonprejudice to national application of penalties and national laws 38 part 8. Any chamber, comprising at least three judges, that the court may form pursuant to article 26, paragraph 1, of the statute to deal with certain categories of cases, such as. Pakistan jadhav case before the international court of justice icj, the icj has published a briefing paper to clarify the key issues and relevant laws raised in the case in a question and answer format the case concerns pakistans failure to allow for consular access to an indian national detained on charges of serious crimes. The refusal of the united states to consider itself bound by the recent decision in the case concerning military and paramilitary activities in and against nicaragua, coupled with the earlier termination of its adherence to article 362 of the statute of the international court of justice, has sparked a small storm of controversy and concern. Jennings, sir robert, the proper work and purposes of the international court of justice, in muller et al.
Article 38 of the statute of the icj sets out the sources from which the court is. A formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute from. The icjs court procedure is set out in the rules of court of the international court of justice, 1978. Article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice. Statute, be referred to the international court of. Article 94 of the united nations charter lays down that each member of the united nations undertakes to comply with the decision of the court in any case to which it is a party. Civil party mr sen sophon giving testimony before the extraordinary chambers in the courts of cambodia in case 00202 against nuon chea and khieu samphan on 27 july 2015. The court, whose function is to decide in accordance with international law such disputes as are submitted to it, shall apply. Although article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice acknowledges that international law draws upon domestic legal systems, the exchange of legal institutions between states and international law has yet to receive similar treatment. This article offers an interpretation of article 381d of the icj statute based on the formal. This article offers an interpretation of article 381d of the icj statute based on the formal pronouncements of international criminal courts and tribunals, distilled from their judgments. Abstractthis article first highlights some salient features of article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice and the applicable law system. Declarations recognizing as compulsory the jurisdiction of the international court of justice under article 36, paragraph 2, of the statute of the court 15 october 1946. A formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute from the.
Article 38 of the statute of the icj establishes the sources of law to be applied by the court in resolving disputes in accordance with international law. International court of justice definition, cases, purpose. The consent of a state to be bound by a treaty which permits a choice. It offers an important forum for the settlement of international economic disputes among states. Penalties 38 article 77 applicable penalties 38 article 78 determination of the sentence 38 article 79 trust fund 38 article 80 nonprejudice to national application of penalties and national laws 38 part 8. The courts reasoning the court begins by considering whether it has jurisdiction prima facie to hear the case.
Article 8 the united nations shall place no restrictions. Article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice usually, the sources of international law are accepted as set out in article 38 1 of the statute of the international court of justice hereinaft er icj statute th irlway 2008, 98, which reproduces almost identically the text of article 38 of. Shahabuddeen observes that, although in the past article 38 1d of the statute of the international court of justice icj statute 1 may not have presented any special difficulty of interpretation, that view is not generally shared today. Its opinions and rulings serve as sources of international law.
The international court of justice and the concept of state practice. International court of justice estab lished by the charter of the. In the event of a dispute as to whether the court has jurisdiction, the matter shall be settled by the decision of the court. It is often observed in the literature on customary international law that the identification practice of the international court of justice icj for customary norms deviates from the traditional definition of customary law in article 38 1 lit. Such subsidiary organs as may be found necessary may be established in accordance with the present charter. It requires the court to apply, among other things, a international conventions, whether general or particular, establishing rules expressly recognized by the contesting states. Duties of ships and aircraft during their passage, research and survey activities, duties of the. In addition, two judges shall be selected for the purpose of replacing judges who find it impossible to sit the statute of the international court of justice article 29. Gozie ogbodo abstract the effectiveness of the international court of justice icj is critical for global survival and progress in the 21st century. Appeal and revision 39 article 81 appeal against decision of acquittal or conviction or against sentence 39.
Formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute. Without prejudice to articles 19 to 23, the consent of a state to be bound by part of a treaty is effective only if the treaty so permits or the other contracting states so agree. Formation and evidence of customary international law. Its opinions and rulings serve as sources of international law the icj is the successor of the permanent court of international justice. Part of this concern involves how the united states. Customary international law must be distinguished from the general principles of law, to which article 381c refers. The law applicable in icj, sec 381 and 2 on the basis of article 38 of icj statute, 5 distinct sources can be identified. This module is intended for those who wish to examine the option of. Article 38 and the hierarchy between the listed sources it is noteworthy that article 38 does not explicitly state that the sources it lists are to be taken. The statute of the international court of justice, part of the charter of the united nations, defines the sources of international law in the following language.
The consent of a state to be bound by a treaty may be expressed by signature, exchange of instruments constituting a treaty, ratification, acceptance, approval or accession, or by any other means if so agreed. United nations convention on the law of the sea contents page. History of article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice. Aerial incident of 10 march 1953 united states of america v. Icj and defender center for human rights submission to the.
C provides the information that must be listed on a notice of intent and includes. Basis of the courts jurisdiction international court of. Article 38 of the statute of the international court of. As is well known, the statute of the international court of justice provides in.
It consists of 15 judgesno two of whom may be nationals of the same statewho are elected. State names which appear in backets are states having made declarations recognizing as compulsory the jurisdiction of the international court of justice for specified periods of time and which have been terminated or have since expired. The free viewer acrobat reader for pdf file is available at the adobe systems. The icj is the principal legal organ of the united nations.
L, international lawmakingarticle 38 of the icj statute reconsidered, in. Judicial decisions are explicitly mentioned in article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice icj as a subsidiary means for the determination of rules of law. An overview of the challenges facing the international court. History of article 38 of the statute of the international. The international court of justice, commonly known as the world court, is the principal judicial organ of the united nations, the icj is a continuing and autonomous body that is permanently in session. An overview of the challenges facing the international. Article 36, paragraph 1, of the statute also provides that the jurisdiction of the court comprises all matters specially provided for in treaties and conventions in force.
Statute of the international court of justice article 1 international court of justice established by the charter of the united nations as the principal judicial organ of the united nations shall be constituted and shall function in accordance with the provisions of the present statute. The brazilian judge and former president of the inter. A formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute from the perspective of the international criminal courts and tribunals. Sources of international law article 38, icj statute international conventions, general principles, customary international law, judicial decisions, teachings of scholars compromissory clause. The meaning and scope of article 38 1 c of the statute of the international court of justice discussion opened by professor h. Formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute from. International court of justice and of other international tribunals are persuasive evidence of what customary international law is and are typically given great weight. The international court of justice established by the charter of the united nations as. It considers that the qualification subsidiary is meant neither to distinguish the means from the primary sources nor to denote of lesser. That consent can take the form of binding treaties or declarations of varying scope. Article 38 of the icj statute defines what sources of law the court shall apply during the proceedings. Despite its multicultural composition, it is only with great difficulty that the court examines questions related to culture. Article 11 means of expressing consent to be bound by a treaty.
Pakistan jadhav case before the international court of justice icj, the icj has published a briefing paper to clarify the key issues and relevant laws raised in the case in a question and answer format. Article 12 consent to be bound by a treaty expressed by signature 1. Statute of the international court of justice article 38 1 this article, describing the law to be applied by the icj when deciding cases within its. Statute of the court international court of justice. The idea for the creation of an international court to arbitrate international disputes first arose during the various conferences that produced the hague conventions in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. These include the primacy of states in international law making and the three dimensional process of identification including proving, interpretation and application of applicable rules of law on the basis of the listed sources of law. Statute of the international court of justice article 36. This contribution to the handbook presents and analyses history of article 38 of the statute. The international court of justice established by the charter of the united nations as the principal judicial organ of the united nations shall be constituted and shall function in accordance with the provisions of the present statute. Jan 27, 2014 in addition, two judges shall be selected for the purpose of replacing judges who find it impossible to sit the statute of the international court of justice article 29.
See paragraph 5 of article 36 of the statute of the. Statute of the international court of justice article 381 this article, describing the law to be applied by the icj when deciding cases within its. The international court of justice icj has never explicitly addressed cultural rights in its case law. There is a clear hierarchy between the sources of international law as laid out in article 381 of the icj statute. A formal approach to article 381d of the icj statute. Islamic law states and the authority of the international. Xviii the icj,3 the rules of procedure adopted by the judges and amended from time to time,4 as well as the practice directions adopted in october 2001. Legal transplants scholarship has thoroughly examined the transnational diffusion of legal institutions. The court may give an advisory opinion on any legal question at the request of whatever.
As is well known, the statute of the international court of justice provides in art. See paragraph 5 of article 36 of the statute of the international court of justice. The icj only has jurisdiction to decide cases that states consent to submit to it for decision. Article 381 of the statute of the international court of justice is widely recognized as the most authoritative statement as to the sources of international law. International court of justice linkedin slideshare. The statute of tjhe international colurt of justice alain pellet. The substantive constitution of the international legal order in respect of sources. Apart from judges with human rights backgrounds, such as rosalyn higgins herself, the first woman to join the court, and the german judge, bruno simma, former member of the human rights committee, the jurisprudence of the court is forged by the experiences of a number of judges with culturally sensitive backgrounds. Unfortunately, after over six decades in existence, the courts influence is declining. The icj recognised that the scope of article 38 of the statute of the international court of justice encompassed bilateral and regional international customary norms as well as general customary norms, in much the same way as it encompasses bilateral and multilateral treaties.
716 1106 575 59 1182 437 359 1597 1173 421 935 688 1482 910 1055 1436 1173 796 716 114 1557 1458 1199 1514 408 1664 1127 1535 540 459 1281 1383 35 927 804 1665 452 1488 1264 986 415 277 185 402 104 218 791 34 1350 887